The Road Between

In the late autumn the dairy roads of central Wisconsin turn hard and pale under the first frost. Along one of them, past the last stand of maples, a man named Eli walked each evening from the barn to the house with a pocket New Testament in his coat. He read as he walked, or rather he paused at the same places he always paused—the low rise where the pasture fell away, the fence corner the heifers used for rubbing—and he read again the verses he had already marked. He was not quick with them. The words came slowly, and often he had to say a sentence twice before it settled. What settled, he carried into the next day’s work.

A farmer in a worn work coat walks a frost-hardened Wisconsin dairy road at dusk, seen from behind, a small Testament in his hand, with a red barn and farmhouse ahead under a violet-and-gold sky.
A pocket New Testament, and the same road home each evening.

Far to the east, in a university office whose windows looked onto a courtyard of bare plane trees, Professor Miriam Hale finished a post she had rewritten three times. It was careful. It named the hypocrisy she had watched in certain congregations, the readiness to judge, the quiet alliance of certain doctrines with certain cultural habits. She wrote of the damage done when certainty outran listening. When she published it, the replies arrived at once, some grateful, some angry. She answered a few, then closed the laptop and sat with her hands around a cup of tea that had gone cold. The arguments were not new to her. She had made them for years. What remained after the posting was a thin, persistent weariness, as if the words had cost something she could not quite name.

Eli had never read her posts. He owned no account on which they could reach him. Once a week, however, his daughter drove down from the city and left a printed page or two on the kitchen table—things she thought he ought to see, arguments about the faith he kept. He read them after the evening chores, under the same lamp, with the same slow attention he gave the Gospels. He did not answer them. He underlined a sentence here and there, then closed the page and opened his Testament again. On those nights he stayed longer at the table. His wife noticed and said nothing. She had learned that the extra time was not argument; it was the quiet work of setting one set of words beside another until something in him grew steady again.

A wooden farmhouse kitchen table at night, lit by a kerosene lamp, with a printed page and an open, worn New Testament beside a mug and an empty chair.
A printed page beside an open Testament, under the kitchen lamp.

One Saturday the daughter brought him into town for a part he could not order. While he waited at the counter, Miriam Hale stood two places ahead of him in the same line, her coat still carrying the chill of the train. They did not speak. She paid and left. He paid and left. On the sidewalk she paused to answer a message; he paused to check the sky the way a man checks weather that still belongs to his animals. For a moment they were near enough that the wind moved both their coats in the same direction. Then the light changed and each went on.

That evening Eli read, as he always did, the passage he had left unfinished the night before. The words did not answer the printed page his daughter had left, nor refute the careful sentences he had only half understood. They did something better: they reminded him whose he was. “Come unto me, all ye that labour and are heavy laden, and I will give you rest.” He had not carried himself down that road all these years; he had been carried, and he knew it. Outside, the first real snow began to settle on the yard. He bowed his head and thanked God for the day, for his daughter, and, to his own surprise, for the woman in the hardware line, whom he commended to the Lord without knowing her name. Then he closed the book, turned off the lamp, and slept the sleep of a man whose accounts had been settled by Another. In the morning the milking would still be there, and the frost on the road, and the same verses waiting, as faithful as the One who gave them.

The first snow of the season falling quietly on a Wisconsin farmyard at night, with a warm lamp glowing in a farmhouse window and bare trees along a fence.
The first real snow began to settle on the yard.

Miriam, in her apartment, scrolled once more through the replies her post had gathered. Some were sharper than she had intended to invite. She set the phone down. The courtyard trees were black against the snow that had reached the city as well. She thought, without deciding anything, of the man in the hardware line whose hands had looked as though they had been in cold water for a long time. She did not know his name. She did not know what he read, or whether he read at all. The thought passed. She opened her notes for the lecture she would give on Monday, and the arguments waited for her, precise and unfinished, as they always were. She worked past midnight. When at last she turned off the light, sleep was slow in coming, and the questions she had answered so carefully for others lay awake beside her, unresolved.


Moral: Arguments about faith can be answered point by point and still leave the one arguing restless and the questions open. The man who keeps returning to Scripture is not held up by his own steadiness but carried by the grace of God, and that grace gives him what no debate can: rest, hope, and a finished work to stand on. Without it, even the sharpest mind lies down at night with things undone.


Discover more from Bob Graham's Blog

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply