Jackie was telling me about a book she read, Ethan Mordden’s All That Glittered, on the golden age of Broadway from 1919 to 1959, and it clicked with something I’ve been watching. A lot of my friends who think this way live in the elite progressive communities that cluster in high-education, high-income suburbs and smaller cities near major metros: places full of professionals, executives, and academics that vote solidly Democratic. Rochester, Minnesota and Madison, Wisconsin are clean examples. In the Mayo Clinic town, dense with physicians, researchers, and administrators, and it went about 59–60% Democratic. Madison is the university town where the academic elites have long dominated, producing the same high-education, solidly Democratic pattern. Inside those circles certain sexual arrangements and identities are treated as basically settled. Question them and you’re not just wrong; you’re provincial, rigid, or low-information. Affirm them, or at least stay carefully unshocked, and you get to feel open, non-judgmental, progressive. That moral flexibility itself becomes your credential.
The same move in an earlier costume
Here’s the part we usually miss: this is not some fresh insight. Mordden’s account of the New York theater elite in the 1920s and ’30s shows the same move. Sophistication there didn’t mean you had an old-money pedigree. It was urbanity, wit, and a racy, worldly openness. Being “sophisticated” meant you weren’t scandalized by unconventional sexual arrangements. Yes, there was “closet” knowledge in many communities, but those “in the know” knew what was going on. The culture was “urban, sophisticated and racy… tinged with an ironic gay sensibility.” If you said nothing about the affairs, the flamboyant personalities, the coded nonconformity, you were cool and in the know. If you thought some of it was disordered, you were the unsophisticated provincial who hadn’t caught up. If you thought it was sinful, you were a puritan bigot.

The status payoff was as real today as it was back then. Treating those things as ordinary marked you as intelligent and free of narrowness; holding the older line cost you standing. People didn’t experience it as relaxing a moral boundary. They experienced it as being worldly and refined. The self-congratulation was the point.
Nothing new under the sun
Today, the vocabulary has shifted from “racy sophistication” to “openness” and “progressiveness,” but the mechanism is the same: You drop an older moral boundary, then treat that drop as proof you’re more sophisticated or enlightened. Once that story is locked in, anyone who still holds the boundary becomes the backward person who makes you look good by comparison. My friends in those communities aren’t uniquely wicked for it. They’re doing what elite subcultures have done for eternity, using the right kind of non-judgment as a badge that separates the sophisticated from the squares. It feels like moral growth because it comes with social rewards and a flattering story about how you’ve moved from Polebridge, Montana to Portland.

What Scripture already saw
Scripture has been calling this out longer than Broadway has existed. Isaiah 5:20–21 is blunt about people who call evil good and good evil, and who are wise in their own eyes. The problem is the pride that turns one’s preferred or cultural norms into the measure of enlightenment. Romans 1 describes the same pattern: people suppress what they know, become futile in their thinking, and still claim to be wise. Their claim to superior sophistication is part of their delusion.
So when the circle treats non-judgment of certain behaviors as proof that they are more advanced than the people who still find their behavior as disordered sin, that’s not a new stage of human development. It’s an old status game. The biblical writers already saw how easily this was “I’m open and non-judgmental” becomes a way of feeling superior while remaining blind to the standard one has quietly discarded.

A mission field
Christians should treat your liberal friends and the elite progressive enclaves where they live as mission fields. I understand why parents would hesitate to raise children in places where these values dominate the air; that kind of exposure is hard, so it has to be a calling rather than a default. But we cannot neglect the gospel in those communities. The same pride that turns moral flexibility into sophistication is exactly the kind of blindness the gospel is meant to address. Preach the gospel to “all.”
Discover more from Bob Graham's Blog
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.