I was reading Schopenhauer the other day, and for a moment I thought he made sense. But the more I read, the more I understood that he was looking at life through the lens of an atheist, and an elite one at that. He wrote of how people look down on those who are structurally ignorant, and how others are belittled for the depth of their intellect. It was there that I remembered the wise and humbling words of C.S. Lewis. Lewis said something very different about the person next to him in church: the one who humbles us by his faithfulness, not his knowledge. That is where I realized Schopenhauer misses the mark.
Lewis’s old saint
Lewis was describing his early experience of churchgoing after becoming a Christian. He had assumed he could manage the Christian life largely alone, through private reading and thinking. Going to church forced him to be among people of different education and outlook. The key moment came while watching ordinary worship:
“I realised that the hymns (which were just sixth-rate music) were, nevertheless, being sung with devotion and benefit by an old saint in elastic-side boots in the opposite pew, and then you realise that you aren’t fit to clean those boots. It gets you out of your solitary conceit.”
In a letter he put it this way:
“I naturally loathe nearly all hymns; the face, and life, of the charwoman in the next pew who revels in them, teach me that good taste in poetry or music are not necessary to salvation.”
The person beside him did not humble Lewis with superior doctrine, sharper arguments, or a deeper intellectual grasp. That person humbled him by simple, lived faithfulness: singing with real devotion, receiving real benefit from God, and continuing in ordinary obedience. Lewis’s refined taste and solitary conceit were exposed as secondary. The saint in elastic-side boots was further along in the thing that actually matters.
Where Schopenhauer misses this
Schopenhauer’s framework has no category for this. For him, the Will is a blind striving; genius is the rare capacity to hit targets others cannot even see; ordinary people forfeit three-quarters of themselves to fit in with society; and productive doubt is the only escape from idiocy. In his view, the ordinary person is structurally limited and locked in, incapable of the higher vision. Intelligence and aesthetic distance are the only ways out.
To me, this sounds like the Ivy League, the elite media, Hollywood, and even the trolls we find on social media. To them, the simple, faithful believer is at best one of the many who cannot see the targets.
Lewis, and the biblical pattern he reflects, reverses that worldly measuring stick. The cross is foolishness to the wise. The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom. The things hidden from the wise and understanding are revealed to little children. “God chose what is foolish in the world to shame the wise; God chose what is weak in the world to shame the strong” (1 Corinthians 1:27).
The person who keeps returning to Scripture, to the work of the cross, and to the ordinary means of grace, even without sophisticated doctrine or the ability to win a debate, can be the one who shows the way. Not by out-arguing the professor or the philosopher, but by a faithfulness that continues while the arguments remain unfinished. That faithfulness does not need to be articulate to be real, and it has the power to humble those who are.
I once considered myself on the wrong side of that line, ashamed that I was not as bright or eloquent, or moving in the “right” circles.
Schopenhauer sees the gap between genius and the ordinary as largely fixed by nature and intellect. Lewis sees the same gap and finds that the ordinary believer’s lived trust can put the intellectual in the place of the one who is “not fit to clean those boots.” The argument is not won on the terms of surface knowledge and certainty. The way is shown by the one who keeps walking it.
Shown in the walking
Here is what I mean. In these exchanges, whether a professor’s careful critique of the church, Schopenhauer’s account of genius and idiocy, or the social-media certainty that rests on surface knowledge, no one “wins” by producing a better argument. The debate stays open. The professor can still list the hypocrisies. The philosopher can still point to the limits of ordinary minds. The confident voice can still sound superior and decisive.
What those arguments cannot close is the ordinary, continued faithfulness of the person who keeps returning to Scripture, to prayer, to the work in front of him, and to the God he is learning to trust. He does not need to out-explain his liberal friends or the atheist critic, or show off superior knowledge. He simply keeps walking the same path: reading the same Book, doing the same work, receiving the same grace, day after day. The path itself becomes visible through him. The way is not proved in the argument; it is shown in the walking.
Lewis’s old saint is the concrete picture. He doesn’t win the debate over which music or which doctrines are essential. He sings, listens to the sermon with devotion, and receives the benefit. The intellectual watching him is left knowing he is “not fit to clean those boots.”
Our own muddy boots do the same thing. A steady return to the Word and to the ordinary duties of life does not refute the professor’s critique, but it shows a reality the critique cannot account for or cancel. The arguments remain unfinished. Our faithfulness continues, and by continuing, it shows the way to eternal glory.
Discover more from Bob Graham's Blog
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.